MALCOLM CAMPBELL'S SHADOWS WEBSITE


A POCKET GUIDE TO SHADOW MUSIC

REVIEWS: RECORD COLLECTOR



  • Source: Record Collector No. 336 (March 2007) p. 124
  • Reviewer:Alan Clayson

    5-star rating:***** As definitive as it could be. While this is a self-published labour of love, it doesn’t blindly praise everything The Shadows ever recorded, with or without Cliff Richard. Wise to individual weaknesses within the flux of personnel over decades, the authors, if proud, even boastful, of the group’s market achievements, pull no punches. When laying into 1965’s “rough, very rough” Nothing Folks (left unreleased until appearing on a CD retrospective) or quoting a disobliging review of a 1981 revival of Telstar (“the horrendous disco drumbeat sticks out like a sore thumb”), they prove themselves clear-headed enough to write a fair book.

    Surely the litmus test for any book, infectious enthusiasm for, say, the string-freighted Atlantis (“something ethereally wistful, yearning about this record”) will make you want to give certain tracks an immediate spin. Crucially, however, this thorough chronicle stands up as a ‘good read’ as much as a painstakenly detailed and indexed track-by-track breakdown, a lot of which is derived from conversations with the band themselves. It includes all the trimmings: composing credits, recording dates, catalogue numbers, you name it, keeping the trivia freak as happy as a sandboy.



  • Return to Home / A Pocket Guide To Shadow Music / Reviews